February 17, 2013
The future of the State of Israel can only be
determined by its own people. Those who only take notice of very critical Israeli
positions ignore the lively and broad spectrum of debate within the country on
its future. In these discussions, statements by critics of Israeli society,
such as those of former politician Avraham Burg, are nothing out of the
ordinary. This type of criticism is an expression of a democratic culture of
debate, one that is unique in the region.
Open discourse such as this is a hallmark of
Israel, which is still the only democracy in the Middle East. While economic
problems, educational inequality, discrimination and other forms of injustice
do exist in Israel – just like in this country – what is truly impressive is
the diversity and peaceful coexistence of vastly different ethnic and cultural
groups in Israel.
Those who talk about Israeli society and overlook
the country’s integrative power ignore the multi-faceted reality of the
country.Members of the Arab minority
represent the State of Israel as senior diplomats and work in the Supreme
Court. According to recent polls, Palestinians living in East Jerusalem would
be more likely to choose Israeli citizenship than Palestinian. While none of
this alters the fact that improving the position of minorities is a challenge
for Israel – as it is for Germany and the United States – significant progress
has been made in this area over the last few decades, which, in Israel’s case,
often goes unnoticed by the German public.
Even today, knowledge of the complex realities of
Israeli society remains rather limited in Germany. Israel often retains a
negative image. Researchers at the Georg Eckart-Institute for the Study of
Schoolbooks in Braunschweig recently published preliminary results of a study
on the representation of Israel in German schoolbooks. They found a high number
of negative representations.
But such a perception is not limited to
schoolbooks. We know from opinion polls that comparisons between policies of
the Nazi regime and those of the State of Israel are widely used, even though
there can be no doubt that such comparisons trivialize the Nazi atrocities. The
claim that Israel represents the biggest threat to world peace is also widely
supported. Statements such as these do not contribute in any way to
reconciliation or peace in the region. On the contrary, they are the unfiltered
extension of old anti-Semitic stereotypes. Such demonizing has nothing to do
with legitimate criticism of Israeli policies.
It would be a great contribution to efforts towards
peace in the region to take a firm stand in the face of propaganda and
agitation against Israel. It would be a great contribution to such efforts to
firmly stand against any attempts to delegitimize the existence of a UN member
state. The terror coming from Hamas in the Gaza Strip and a Hezbollah under
Iranian control continues to be a threat to the security of the State of
In a situation like this, Israel needs Germany to
be an understanding partner for the country’s position as the only democracy in
a region where oppression, despotism and authoritarian regimes are the norm.
Israel shares Germany’s commitment to values such as freedom, democracy and
The open discourse within Israeli society is a
clear sign that these values are deeply entrenched in the country’s social
fabric. This is one of the reasons why close relations with the State of Israel
remain one of the pillars of German foreign policy. A positive contribution to
a peaceful future in the Middle East can only be made on the basis of this kind
of common ground between Germany and Israel.
Deidre Berger is Director of AJC's Berlin Ramer Institute for
German–Jewish Relations.Date: 2/19/2013 12:00:00 AM